Home
About Staff
Margien's Commentaries

 

July 29, 2007
Deathly Hallows Yeahs & Nays
July 27, 2007
Photos from B&N HP Party
July 18, 2007
Deathly Hallows - 11th Hour...
July 14, 2007
Enchantments Page Update
July 14, 2007
List the 7 Horcruxes Contest!
July 13, 2007
New OOtP Soundtrack!
June 12, 2007
Sonorus 2007 - Brilliant!
May 19 2007
Sonorus 2007, Judy Burns and Moi
 

Clues and Theories A - Z

Beasts and Other Things That Go Bump in the Night
Enchantments
Locations - Plotable and       Unplotable
Magical Miscellany
Muggles, Witches, Wizards and   Other Non-Humans
Number-ology
OWLs  - Passing, Not Flying
 

Books and Covers
HBP Predictions
HBP ABSOLUTE SPOILERS!!!
 

Harry Potter and the...
     Sorcerer's Stone
     Chamber of Secrets
     Prisoner of Azkaban
     Goblet of Fire
     Order of the Phoenix
     Half-Blood Prince
     Movie 7
 
A Connecticut Yankee...and Harry
Bell, Book and Candle 
I Married a Witch
Spirited Away/HP Comparison
The 7 Faces of Dr. Lao
 
Margien and Mom's New Book!
Press Release for Eloise DVDs
 

Charlie Bone and Harry Potter

Harold and Harry - A Closer L@@k

Harry Houdini - Magical Muggle
Trick - Japanese Series HP Episode Take-off

Contact Web Wizardess

Potter Polls
Puzzling Questions
Trivia for the Experts
Harry Potter book 7, film 5 news, images, interviews, merchandise and more
Visit MuggleNet.com!
 

HP  and Other Great Websites
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

PUZZLING QUESTIONS

 

With each Harry Potter book and movies there have popped up some puzzling  questions in many fans heads.  Jo Rowling has answered quite a few of these and continues to offer explanations or fixes to appease us.  Here are a few more brain teasers that have been swirling around in my brain.  In some cases I have offered reasons or solutions to my own queries.  Others are up for grabs to anyone, including Jo to answer... and since some of these questions have also been asked by mugglenet.com and hp-lexicon.org answers have already and , I'm sure, will continue to materialize.       

*    What is the Half-Blood Prince "prince" of?  Is he the future ruler of the UK?  Or another nation?  Maybe he is the future King of all wizards, witches and the magical realm?  And is he a good prince or a bad prince?  We already have an evil lord in the guise of Voldemort, and Harry is likened to the legendary Arthur.  So where does the mysterious half-blood ?future king? fit in?  And yet another question pops to mind:  since he is apparently not  a pure blood of  whatever his lineage descends from, can he ever truly be king?  Here's a thought -- maybe he is the prince of all half-bloods.   Hmmm, well maybe that is stretching it a bit. 

*    In OotP, how is it that Neville was able to touch and hold the glass orb containing Harry’s prophecy without going insane like Broderick Bode?  Perhaps the reason is because Neville could have been the child the prophecy was actually about?

*    In OotP, when Harry is brought before the Wizengamot, why doesn't Dumbledore suggest  to Fudge just give him Veritas serum to get the truth about the dementors?    And why doesn't Fudge think of this on his own?  My own answer to this is that Fudge really wants to get Harry out of the way as well as Dumbledore so he doesn't want to hear the truth.  And Umbridge would naturally veer away from using Veritas serum in this instance because she's the one who sent the dementors after Harry in the first place. 

*    In COS, Hermione, Colin Creevey and Justin Finch-Fletchly are all petrified.  Were their parents notified and wouldn't they have come to Howarts to see their children and talk to Dumbledore?  I imagine that maybe they did and we just didn't hear ab about it... but I'm surprized Harry and Ron wouldn't have seen Hermione's parents.  After all, in OotPwhen a disoriented Montague was finally found after Fred and George had stuffed down a girl's toilet, Harry saw his parents come to take him home.

*     Also in CoS, how is it that Professor McGonagall  knows that it is Ginny Weasley who has been taken  into the Chamber of Secrets.  Ginny's name is painted on the wall where it says, "Her skeleton will lie in the Chamber forever."  Was there another note just sent to McGonagall?  Did she see Ginny being taken?  How did she know?

*   Who has Mad-Eye Moody's other invisibility cloak... the one that Sturgeus Podmore was using when he was arrested for trying to break into the Department of Mysteries?  Since Sturgeus was under the influence of the Imperius Curse it could be that a death eater has the cloak... or maybe Fudge has it?  Since we can safely assume that Fudge will be high-tailing it out of the Ministry in HBP he might find it very handy to have an invisibility cloak.... just a guess.

*   Where did they take Barty Croutch Jr. after his soul had been sucked out by the dementors.  Did Fudge have him returned to Azkaban?  Or is he at St. Mungos?  Does St Mungos have private wards where visitors aren't allowed?  And can the body of a person who's soul has been sucked out be  possessed?

*  When Barty Croutch confessed under the influence of Veritaserum he said, in Snape's presence, that he stole the Gillyweed from Snape's office.  So Snape knows for a fact that Harry didn't do it.  So why doesn't he acknowledge this at least with a look to Harry?  Well, of course he also knows that Harry was out wandering around in his invisibility cloak that night so it's a mute point, I suppose.

*    Does Sirius's godfather authority hold up even after death?  Specifically, will Harry be allowed to visit Hogsmeade now that his godfather is dead and no longer responsible for him?    I think Dumbledore will continue to honor Sirius's wishes and that Harry will be able to go to Hogsmeade... on the up and up.  Of course, he'll go regardless knowing Harry, even if he has to resort to hidden tunnels and his invisibility cloak. 

*    In PS/SS on the Hogwarts Express, Hermione tells Harry and Ron  that she has tried a few practice spells.  Isn't that illegal because she was an under-aged wizard who knowingly  used magic outside of Hogwarts?    Technically, yes.  however, maybe because she hadn't yet been told that she's not allowed to use magic outside of Hogwarts it doesn't count; she can claim ignorance.  Harry never saw so much as a an owl feather let alone an owl bringing warnings from the Ministry until after his first year at Hogwarts.  Also, apparently, the Hogwarts Express counts as part of the school grounds since students are constantly doing magic on the train but are never called down for it.

*   Harry, Ron, Hermione, and Draco are all given detention by McGonagall.  Isn't interesting that students are forbidden to go into the Forbidden Forest, yet that is where they are taken during their detention?  Not only that but Hagrid splits them up and so that Harry, Neville and Draco are without an adult part of the time.   Granted, nobody expected Voldemort to be gliding and swooping around in the Forbidden Forest  at the time but as Draco says, there are werewolves in there... and giant spiders and all sorts of deadly things.   Well, dramatic license is allowed where it moves the story along and adds tension when and where it's needed.

*   Are watches other than the old-fashioned windup kind considered electrical devises?  If they are and that’s what Harry has then how does it work?  Or is he wearing an antique?

*   How is Hogarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry funded?  Do students pay tuition?  Are there private donations?  Did the original founders set up a trust fund?  Or does the Ministry of Magic have an educational fund that is collected by taxing the wizard community?  I can't think that the students pay a tuition because then families like the Weasleys couldn't afford to send their children to Hogwarts.  However, it seems likely that Hogwarts probably does accept donations which it puts into a trust fund and the money is in an account at Gringotts Bank where it would collect interest.  Howartts probably also does get funded by the Ministry of Magic... so Fudge could, in his paranoid little mind, rationalize that he would be able to set amazingly irrational mandates to govern the students, teachers, etc.

*   Where does Remus Lupin live?  He has a place because Dumbledore told Sirius to hold up with Lupin at the end of GoF.  And even though Sirius moved into his old family home at 12 Grimmauld Place, I don't think Lupin took up residence there too.

*   Percy Weasley rented a flat in London when he moved out of the Burrow.  Did he rent from wizards or muggles?

 

 

 

BACK TO THE TOP 

 

      

 

 

 

Counter
Counter

Click for the Harry Potter Online Shop-WBShop.com

WB Shop Affiliate

Click here to buy

posters!

 In association with Amazon.com

 

 

This web site page was created and is maintained and updated by a fan of the Harry Potter books and films. Access to this web site is free and public.    Harry Potter and all related film material including characters, images, and elements are trademarks of and © Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.  Harry Potter Publishing Rights are and all other proper names from the Harry Potter series are © Joanne Kathleen Rowling aka JKR. The Mirror of Erised web site is in no way affiliated with J.K. Rowling, Scholastic Books, Carlsen Verlag, Bloomsbury Publishing or Warner Bros.  Materials and/or images related to the J.K. Rowling novels are copyright Scholastic Books (United States) Carlsen Verlag (Germany), and Bloomsbury Publishing (United Kingdom). 

This web site is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Lucasfilm Ltd. or Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate.  All copyrights and trademarks for all materials used at this web site mentioned or relating to Star Wars or The Lord of the Rings are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law.

© Original content copyright 2004, 2005 by Margien Burns. All rights reserved.